How to Post Your Game on Reddit Without Getting Removed
You spent a weekend cutting a trailer, posted it to three subreddits, and woke up to two upvotes, one removal notice and a comment calling it spam.

You spent a weekend cutting a trailer, posted it to three subreddits, and woke up to two upvotes, one removal notice and a comment calling it spam. If you want to post your game on Reddit and actually get players or feedback, the problem is rarely the game. It is usually where, when and how the post goes up.
I have shared our small projects on Reddit for about five years, from Scratch prototypes to a Godot game that ended up with a few thousand wishlists. Some posts did nothing. A few did more than any paid promotion we tried. The difference came down to a short list of habits.
Why most attempts to post your game on Reddit fail
Reddit is not one site. It is thousands of small communities, each with moderators, rules and a sense of what belongs. A post that does well in r/IndieDev can get deleted in r/gaming within minutes, because many large general subreddits restrict self promotion or limit it to specific days.
The three causes I see most:
- Brand new or promotion-only accounts. Many subreddits use automatic filters for accounts under a certain age or karma. Your post may be removed before a human sees it.
- Ignoring the sidebar rules. Some communities require a flair, a specific title format or a ratio of promotion to normal participation.
- Posting a link instead of a moment. A store link with "check out my game" gives people nothing to react to.
Pick subreddits that match the stage of your game
Where you post should depend on what you want back. Early in development you want feedback from other makers. Near launch you want players.
| Goal | Good places to start | What works there |
|---|---|---|
| Feedback on mechanics | r/gamedev weekly threads, engine subs like r/godot or r/Unity3D | Short clips with a specific question |
| Showing progress | r/IndieDev, r/indiegames | Before and after GIFs, devlog moments |
| Finding players | Genre subs like r/roguelikes or r/CozyGamers | Gameplay that fits the genre, honest descriptions |
| Scratch projects | r/scratch | Project links with what you learned |
Before you post anywhere, scroll the top posts of the past month. If nothing like your post is up there, it probably will not land either.
Write a post people want to engage with
The posts that worked best for us all shared the same shape: one striking visual, a plain title and a real question.
The visual
A 5 to 15 second GIF or video that shows one thing happening. A dash that leaves afterimages, a level collapsing, a cat knocking a cup off a table in your physics game. Upload it natively to Reddit rather than linking to another site. Native video autoplays in the feed and gets far more views. Our guide on sharing a game build before it is finished goes deeper on picking the right moment to show.
The title
Describe what the clip shows, not what you want. "I added a grappling hook that lets you swing off enemies" beats "My indie game, wishlist on Steam!" Keep it under about 100 characters so it does not get cut off on mobile.
The first comment
Post a comment yourself within a minute of submitting. Include the game name, engine, how long you have worked on it, a specific question, and the store or itch.io link if the subreddit allows it. Putting the link in a comment instead of the post itself is accepted in many communities that frown on direct links.
Timing, frequency and the 10 to 1 habit
Most of the English language audience is in North America and Europe. For our posts, weekday mornings Eastern time, roughly 8 to 11 am, consistently outperformed evenings. Tuesday through Thursday did a bit better than weekends, except for themed days like Screenshot Saturday that some communities run.
How often should you post? In any single subreddit, once every one to two weeks is the most I would risk. More than that and regulars start recognizing your game as an ad.
The habit that changed our results most was spending time in the community between posts. Comment on other people's work, answer questions in engine subs, give useful notes on other games. A rough guideline many developers repeat is about ten genuine contributions for every self promotional post. Treat it as a minimum, not a quota to game. If you need help writing useful notes, see our piece on giving useful feedback on other people's games.
The counter-take: do not chase the front page
Plenty of advice treats a viral Reddit post as the goal. Hit the top of r/gaming, the theory goes, and wishlists will pour in. I think chasing that is mostly a waste of a small team's energy.
A huge post in a general subreddit brings a spike of visitors who scroll past dozens of games a day. In our experience, a post with 300 upvotes in a genre subreddit full of people who love that exact kind of game converted to more wishlists and Discord joins than a post with 8,000 upvotes in a general one. Aim for the smallest community where your game is an obvious fit, then build from there.
Handling comments and criticism
Reply to every serious comment in the first two hours. Early replies push the post higher and show you are a person, not a marketing account. When someone criticizes the art or the controls, thank them and ask a follow up question. "Which part felt floaty, the jump or the landing?" turns a drive by complaint into usable feedback. Never argue, even if the comment is unfair. Other readers judge the game partly by how you respond.
Afterward, note which subreddit, time, title and clip you used and what came of it. After five or six posts you will see your own patterns. For the wider picture of getting people to play your work, read sharing your game so people actually play it.
Frequently asked questions
Is it allowed to promote your own game on Reddit?
Yes, in many subreddits, but each community sets its own rules. Some allow it any day, some only on specific weekly threads, and some ban it entirely. Always read the sidebar and pinned posts first, and participate normally so your account is not only promotion.
What is the best subreddit to post your indie game?
There is no single best one. r/IndieDev and r/indiegames are friendly to developers showing work, while genre subreddits are better for finding players. The best choice is the smallest community where your game is a clear match.
Why was my Reddit post removed automatically?
Automatic removals usually come from filters on account age, karma or link domains, or from a missing flair or title format. Message the moderators politely to ask what rule applied. They often explain and sometimes approve the post manually.
More in Community
Community
How to Host a Small Game Jam for Your Own Community
The first jam I organised had 34 people sign up and four submissions.
Community
How to Find a Game Dev Partner for a Small Project
You can code but your art looks like placeholder boxes, or you can draw but every script you write breaks the moment you add a...
Community
How to Handle Negative Feedback on Your Indie Game
You posted your build, waited all evening, and the first comment says the controls feel awful and the art looks like a...